Stereogum had the following to say about Paxton-Beesley's new mixtape:
"River Tiber aka Tommy Paxton-Beesley got a much deserved boost earlier this year when Drake sampled his song “No Talk” for “No Tellin'” one of the best and most introspective tracks off his surprise “mixtape” If You’re Reading This It’s Too Late. His smeared R&B sound lends itself easily to Drake’s oeuvre, but River Tiber manages to expand well into his own territory with electronic darkness and a delicate ambience that’s all his own."